Surface to air missile non-comparison table

[Range/aspect diagram] Missile range very much depends on target speed and aspect.

A nominal range of X km usually means that you can hit aircraft which are flying towards you at that range. Typically, they can pass to the side of you at about half that distance without risk beeing hit.

This diagram is adapted from 1976 data for RBS 70, with a nominal range (then) of 5 km. Target speed is assumed at 250 m/s. For it, at speeds over 300 m/s, there is no rear coverage at all, and for speeds of 50 m/s, the diagram is virtually circular out to 5 km.


[Engagement altitude diagram] Altitude also has a large impact on range.

The missile looses energy as it climbs, but at low altitude air resistance is greater.


[Missile speed falloff diagram] All missiles of course also have greater intercept probability when they have high energy, ie is moving faster, and that's closer to the launcher, before or soon after motor burn out. At any range, there's a certain amount of turning they're capable of, before they literally fall out of the sky.

This diagram is for the Crotale NG VT-1 missile with a speed of Mach 3.5 and a range of 10 km+. Other data for this missile is that it reaches 8 km in 10 s, and that at 8 km it's capable of making 35G turns and that the warhead's lethal radius is 8 m. But I don't know how much it can turn at 35G before losing too much speed to fly.


Legend: BR=Beamrider, CC=Command Control, IR=Infrared, SAR=Semiactive Radar, CLOS=Command to Line Of Sight, SACLOS=Semiactive CLOS, LBR=Laser BR

     Guidance Range  Altitude Speed,Mach  Warhead
Designation   Min/max,km   m       Weight,kg  Length/diam./span,cm

CHINA
HQ-2Y   CC,SAR 7/35 500/27k   3.6 2300    ?   1080/50-65/170
HN-5A      IR 0.8/4  80/2500   ?      13  ?
        HN, Hong Nu = Red Cherry, short range SAMs
QW-1       IR 0.5/5  30/4000   ?      17  ?
HQ/HY-61M  SAR 3/10  /8k      3    300   40   399/29/112   "CSA-N-1"
        HQ, Hong Qi = Red Flag, medium/long range SAMs
KS-1           7/42 500/25k   4    900    ?   560/40/120
It is designed for targets at medium-high altitude, including high-altitude
recon. aircraft, unmanned recon. aircraft, helicopter, and air-surface     
missile (<= 750m/s and <= 4-5g). It may NOT be launched vertically         
like Russian SA-10.                                                        
LY-60    SAR    /   30/12k    3.6             390/20/68

Air defence weapons of the PLA


EGYPT
SakrFactory
Ain Sakr  IR    /4.4 50/2400  ?     10        134/7/10    Egyptian Strela

FRANCE
Mistral   IR 0.3/6    /3000   2.6   17    3
Mistral 2 IR   ?/6+   /?      2.6+            Previously classified, revealed and
    entered service in 2000. Compatible with the earlier variant which is no longer
    built. New seeker processor and rear wing and some other systems. Faster, more
    agile and longer range.
Matra
Crotale IR/BR 0.5/10 4/5000   2.3   85   14   293/16/54
French Navy
Masurca   SAR   /50  30/23k   3    950  120   538/41/77
              5
France/UK/Italy
ASTER 15  AR 1.7/15   ?       ?      ?    3
ASTER 30  AR   3/80   /15000  4      ?    ?
   Uses the same dart, which with thrusters manouvers at up to 50G lateraly.
SAAM/FR and SAAM/IT uses the ASTER 15 missile
PAAMS/SAAM AD uses both, SAMP/T is a land based version with radar, operations
centre and up to six eight missile launchers, with ATBM capability (Block 1)
against 600 km range missiles.
SAAM and SAMP/T tracks 100 targets, engages 10.
SAAM AD tracks 300 targets, engages 12.
Both updates missiles in flight (up to 16) once per second with target position
until the missile's own radar locks on.

FRANCE/GERMANY
Euromissile
Roland   CLOS 0.5/6.3 20/4000 1.5   67    6.5 240/16/50   Radar/optical CLOS
Roland 3 IR/SACLOS 0.5/8 20/4000 1.7 67   9   240/16/50
Roland M5     1.5/12 /8000    5          11   255/17/35
  >Mach 3 at 5-10 km, 70G to 8 km, 45 G at 10 km, 25G at 12 km

GERMANY
Wasserfall CLOS 5/25 1/18     1.5  4000  250 7500/75/160  Never operational
   Warhead was to be distributed to reduce damage on the ground in case it missed.
   Radio proximity fuze planned.
Reintochter CC   /40  /6      1    1700  100

BGT
LFK NG LeFLa     /8+  ?       2.5    19       180/90/?    Development planned in 2000
Based on the IRIS-T, much smaller. Also intended as a helicopter AAM.
Will include a non-line of sight mode.
Two dimensional single colour imaging seeker matrix.
Instead of a dual pulse motor, it will have a sustainer motor
with four angled nozzles ahead of the wings.

GERMANY/USA
Raytheon Defense Systems (Hughes)/Ramsys
RIM-116  IR+RF /7     ?       >1     73   11     /13/43    Rolling Airframe Missile
   The Block 1 improvment (IRMU, IR Mode Upgrade) allows the missile
   to engage targets using IR only.

INDIA
Thrishul        /9        to be test fired 2004
Akash           /25       to be test fired 2004

ISRAEL
Barak-1  CLOS 0.5/10   ?       1.8   98   22
BARAK/ADAMS

Spyder
A system with ground launched Python 5 (out to 20 km) and Derby
missiles (out to 40 km with a booster developed from
Barak)

IAI
Arrow 2
One battery delivered, one being built, the third funded (2000) will
together cover Israel.
A battery has four launch vehicles with six ready missiles each, 
a Tadiran Citron Tree launch control centre, a Hazelnut Tree fire
control centre which can handle 14 simultaneous intercepts, one 
Elta Green Pine radar which tracks targets up to 500 km away
with one trailer with a radar control centre, one with its power
unit and one with its cooling unit.

ITALY
Alenia Difesa
Aspide   SAR  /15    15/5000  2    204   33   370/20/68
Aspide 2000   /24      ?      ?      ?    ?   ?        
       Faster, better lateral acceleration, longer range, compatible
       with all Aspide or Sea Sparrow launchers.

JAPAN
Toshiba
TAN-SAM  IR 0.5/7   /3000     2.4  100    ?   270/16/60    "Type 81"

NORWAY
NASAMS   AR    /20  /         4    157        365/18/53   
[1] [2]
  Ground launched AMRAAM. 
  (Larger, elliptical cross section motor possible. (1999))
  One battery has nine launchers, each with six ready to fire missiles.
  It can work as three independent units with one radar and three launchers each.
  All 54 can be fired at different targets within 12 s.
  Up to four AN/TPQ-36A (update to AN/MPQ-64 planned) radars and IR Norwegian
  Tracking Adjuct Systems belong to a battery, launchers can be sited
  25 km from them, instrumented range is 75 km, fighters can be detected at 60 km.

PAKISTAN
Anza Mk1 1.2/4  80/2500?  ?      13  ?    Similar to the HN-5
RUSSIA
S-25         ?   ?     ?         ?       ?    ? 1200/70/250   "SA-1 Guild"
   S-25 Berkut (Beria-Kutepov)/Systema 25, deployed in two rings around Moscow, at 40 and 90 km,
   could track 10 targets and guide 1 (or perhaps 2) missiles against each
KB-1      CC   /50   /28k     >3.5 2300  130 1070/70/220   "SA-2 Guideline"
S-125 Neva
   Pechora CC 6/35 100-300/15k 2    600   60  670/70/150   "SA-3/SA-N-1 Goa"
   Pechora-2   Upgrade with digital fire control units and better ECCM (example: Egypt in 1999)
       CC/SAR 6/55  90/24500   2.8    ?   98  640/70/170   "SA-N-3 Goblet"
9M8 Krug   CC  /70   /25k      2.5 1000    ?  900/80/260   "SA-4 Ganef"
S-200     SAR 80/250 /30k     >3.5 9000    ? 1650/100/396  "SA-5 Gammon"
    Max target speed 4300m/s
ZRK-SD Kub CC/SAR /35 100/13k  2.8  550   80  620/34/152   "SA-6 Gainful"
Strela    IR  0.5/3.7 45/3000  1.8    9    2  135/?/?      "SA-7/SA-N-5 Grail"
Strela-2M IR  0.5/5.6 45/4300  1.8?  10    ?               "SA-7B Grail"
    Can be fitted with the 9E46M dual colour IR seeker from
    Igla, but as it's slower it's not given the Igla's aerospike. No customer yet.
    (Speeds given by KBM, Strela-2M: 51200 ft/min, Igla: 78700 ft/min)
Igla-1 9K310 IR 0.5/6 /5000    2.5?  13    2  ?            "SA-16 Gimlet"
9M33 Romb CC  1.6/15 9/3000    2    180   19  320/21/64    "SA-8/SA-N-4 Gecko"
  Vehicle with six-round launcher and radars, normal crew six. 
  C-band search radar, 40 km range, tracking radar with 28 km range.
  Normal tactic is to fire two missiles, each guided on a separate Ku-band
  channel. Backup tracking via TV.
          IR  0.5/6  /5000    >1.5   30    3  180/11/30    "SA-9 Gaskin"
S-300PMU1 SAR/AR 5/70 300/30k  5   1500  130  780/50/100   "SA-10/SA-N-6 Grumble"
  Extended range version of S-300PMU (SA-10B), with some anti 
  ballistic missile capability. Max aerodynamic target speed 3000m/s.
S-300PMU2 Favorit   A variant of the S-300PMU1, range 50 km more at 200 km,
  minimum range 2 km, new missile with larger warhead and better guidance.
  Fakel 9M96E (max range 40 km) and 9M96E2 (max range 120 km), launched
  vertically from "cold" launchers are also associated with the 
  "Triumph" system under development.
S-300VM  Another modification, tested in 1998: All new electronics, modernized radar 
  and improved missiles. Range is increased to 200 km, they are faster and have higher G load at 28G.

9M311 SACLOS  0.5/8    ?       3.5    ?    9  ?         "SA-19/SA-N-11 Grisom"
Tor  SAR/CC+AR 0.5/19  ?       2.5    ?   15  ?         "SA-15/SA-N-9 Gauntlet"
   9K331 Tor, SA-15 GAUNTLET, SA-N-9, HQ-17
        IR    0.5/5    ?       2      ?    3  ?            "SA-13 Gopher"
        IR    0.5/6  /5000     1.8   10    2  ?          "SA-14/SA-N-8 Gremlin"
9K37M1 Buk SAR 3/32  15/22k    3    690   70  555/40/86  "SA-11/SA-N-7 Gadfly"
  aka Gang SA-N-7=Shtil. 20G turns. Closing targets M2.5, receding M0.9, also
  ATBM. Track 75, follow 15, engage 6. 60 m target detected at 35 km, high at
  160 km. 400 m range resolution, 3-4.5 deg azimut and elevation.
S-300V  200 targets identified, 70 tracked, 24 engaged with 2-4 missiles,
  48 missiles in flight, one fired every 1.5s.
 9M82  SAR    13/100 1000/30k >7   4500  150 9500/?/-      "SA-12B Giant"
  Range at ballistic targets 40 km
 9M83  SAR   6-8/75  25/25k   >5   2000  150 8000/?/-      "SA-12A Gladiator"
9K40M Ural                                                 "SA-17 Grizzly"

SOUTH AFRICA
Kentron
SAVH-3         /12    ?       3.5  123   22   308/18/40    Mach 1.5 at 12 km
 40G lateral accelation, 6G at 7000 m, 10 s to 8 km, <17.5 s to 12 common
 RF/laser/command link, SAVH-IRS dual-colour IR, SAVH-RS pulse-doppler+ HOJ

Umkhonto CC+IR /8-12  /7300   ?    125    ?   300/18/?       Naval VL SAM
  First intended to get air cooled IR seeker from U-Darter,
  will now probably get a simpler variant. TVC + tail control as on SAHV-3.

SOUTH KOREA

Chumna         2/10          2.6                           ("Pegasus") Based on Crotale

SWEDEN
Bofors
RBS 70      LBR 0.2/5   0/3000  1.6     17    1   132/11/32
RBS 90    LBR 0.2/7   0/3000  1.7     17    1+   132/11/32
BOLIDE       0.25/8   0/5000     RBS70/90 compatible, faster, better
  against agile targets, programmable gyro, adaptable proximity fuze,
  new kind of rocket fuel.  Production to start in 2002 (decision in 2001).
RBS23    CC    /15   /15k    3       80    230/11(20)/29(53) Bamse
  Accelerates to 1000 m/s in < 1 s.
  The Swedish air defence command on RBS 23
  Bofors on BAMSE
  Lv 7 photos BAMSE=RBS23=Robotsystem 23
  The BAMSE system consists of UndE which gathers information about the air
  defence situation, with its own 3D radar (PS-70 / PS-90 development) and from
  other sources and the launch unit EldE, which is towed and has room
  for two operators. On the roof are four missile launchers and a 8 m sensor
  mast. The main sensor is a Ka-band radar which tracks the targets and the
  missiles as well as transmit steering commands to the missile, backup sensor
  is IR. Warhead   fusing is either direct hit or proximity fuze, for good
  effect against small targets too.
Abraham   Low cost hypervelocity air defence reatil ("reaction projectile") Abraham. 
  Calibre 120 mm, mass 25 kg, 10 kg steel ball directed warhead at targets up to 
  90 m to the side of the trajectory by a laser fuze. As previously known, 
  there basically isn't any user interface except an on/off switch and 
  controls for setting engagement zones. It's not been ordered yet (2001).

TAIWAN
CSIST
Tien Kung 1 SAR/IR /70 100/24k 4+                      Sky Bow 1
Tien Kung 2    /140    /30k    ?                       
Tien Kung 2A   ATBM version, test fired 1997-8
Tien Ji        SSM version of Tien Kung 2, range up to 300 km
Tien Kung 3    Future hypersonic rocket/ramjet
Antelope       /9    15/3000   Based on Tien Chien I AAM, four round launcher

UK
Hawker Siddeley Dynamics
Sea Dart SAR   />80  30/25k    3.5   550  ?   440/42/91         Ramjet
Seaslug  BR    /45+  /15k+     ?       ?  ?   610/41/144        Ramjet

British Aircraft Corporation
Bloodhound 2 SAR />80          ?       ?   ?  846/55/283        Ramjet
Thunderbird 2 SAR />75?        ?       ?   ?  635/53/163
Rapier  SACLOS 0.5/7 0/3000   >2      43   0.5 224/13/38
Rapier 2000 ACLOS 0.5/7  0/3000  >2   43   9   224/13/38
Seawolf CLOS   /5             >2      82      190/18/56

Short Brothers
Seacat   CLOS  /5    6/1000    0.9    68  15  147/19/65  Land=Tigercat
Blowpipe IR/CLOS 0.5/>3 /2000  1.5    11   2.2 140/8/28
Javelin SACLOS 0.5/5.6 ?       2.3    13   3   ?
Starburst  LBR /4.4-5.5 /3000 >1      15   3   140/20/   range 4.4 against fast targets; 5.5 slow
Starstreak LBR ?     ?         3       ?   ?   ?  Three darts, time of flight to 4 km 5 s

UK/France
Matra BAe Dynamics
Jernas ACLOS 0.5/8  0/3000    >2.5 43   9   224/13/38   >30G turns
    Jernas Field Standard C is an export version of Rapier FSC
    with Rapier 2000 missile, Dagger surveillance and Blindfire targeting radars. 
    Rapier FSC is in service since 1996.


USA
Bendix
RIM-8  BR/SAR  /120   ?        3.5  3175   ?  640/76/290   Talos, ramjet
    One version with a 5kT nuclear W-30 warhead

Raytheon Defense Systems (/General Dynamics/Hughes)
RIM-7H   SAR  1/18  15/5000    3.5   205  30  365/20/102   Sea Sparrow
    Mostly similar to AIM-7E
RIM-7M   Developed together with AIM-7M (1976, IOC 1982)
RIM-7P   CC+SAR   Command control link allows for trajectory control and
    dive attacks against low flying targets.
RIM-8R   CC+SAR+IR Cancelled

Raytheon Defense Systems (Hughes)
ESSM  Evolved Sea Sparrow, under development

Raytheon Defense Systems (General Dynamics)
RIM-2    BR+SAR /35   ?        2.9  1360   ?  823/34-46/?  Terrier
RIM-24   SAR   /26    ?        ?     590   ?  457/34/?     Tartar
RIM-66A  SAR   /46  45/19k    >2     608  97  472/34/91    Standard SM-1 MR
RIM-66C  SAR   /74    /24k    >2     704  97  472/34/91    Standard SM-2 MR
RIM-67B  SAR   /150   /30k    >2.5  1440  97  798/34/94    Standard SM-2 ER

Raytheon
MIM-23A  SAR   /35   ?         ?     587   ?  508/37/120   Hawk
MIM-23B  SAR   /40   30/18k    2.5   625  54  508/37/120   IHawk
   40 km range for low altitude targets, 35 for max altitude
MIM-104A       /60   /24k      3     914  90  530/41/92    Patriot IOC 1984
   After launch intertially guided with command updates. Terminal intercept
   is semi-active radar, with Track-Via-Missile (the missile downlinks target
   position to the ground station).
   When set up, can be launched in a 60 deg arc.
   Warhead with 2 g fragments.
MIM-104B
   As MIM-104A, added surface to surface lofted trajectory mode to be used
   against jammers.  
 PAC-1 Patriot Advanced Capability (IOC 1989).
   Missile unchanged. Radar elevation increased from 45 to 90 degrees.
   Software upgrade to protect a radius of 5 km around the launcher
   against Scud missiles.
MIM-104C      3/70+  /24k      ?     900  91  518/41/92 (IOC 1990) (Perhaps up to 160 km range?)
 PAC-2. Improved ground software.
   Warhead with 45 g fragments, two-beam proximity fuze (one narrower
   cone against faster, ballistic missiles, targets).
MIM-104D                                                (IOC 1994)
 PAC-2/GEM (Guidance Enhanced Missile). 
   Faster fuze, faster and more sensitive seeker.
MIM-104E  Further PAC-2 improvements? Status?
 PAC-3 Configuration 1 (1995)
   New pulse doppler processor, engagement control improvements,
   PAC-2/GEM missiles.
 PAC-3 Conf. 2 (1996) 
   Better communications computer, JTIDS interface, PDB-4 software
   for better performance against low RCS targets and anti-radiation missiles.
ERINT  AR      /40?  /15k?     5?    312  73  520/25/50 
 PAC-3 Conf. 3 (IOC 2003) 
   Upgraded radar with two twin TWT, new emitter for improved performance
   in clutter, remote control distance increased to 30 km (from 10),
   uses both ERINT (hit to kill) and PAC-2/GEM missiles.
   Launcher can take four PAC-2 or sixteen ERINT.
   ERINT has an explosive warhead for use against airbreathing targets.
   Before launch the missile receives only class of target, target vector
   and predicted intercept point, after that the missile uses its own 
   radar and performs all calculations needed, but uses a two way datalink
   to exchange target data with the ground station. ERINT has rear aerodynamic
   control surfaces and lateral thrusters.
   Normal US battery will consist of six PAC-2 and two ERINT launchers.
   For anti ballistic missile targets standard engagement is two ripple fired missiles.
Raytheon MIM-104 Patriot, Patriot PAC-3 Missile System, Patriot Advanced Capability-3
Vehicle with raised launcher HUMRAAM Ground launched AMRAAM, like NASAMS but pedestal, x5, instead of cannister launched. HUMRAAM live fire

Raytheon Defense Systems (General Dynamics/Hughes)
FIM-43A  IR    /3.4  /1500     ?       8   ?  122/7/14     Redeye
FIM-92A  IR 0.3/5.5 30/4800     2.2   10   2  152/7/9      Stinger
FIM-92B/C IR/UV 0.2/5.5 30/4800 2.2   10   3  152/7/9      Stinger
   FM 44-18 (Air defence employment Stinger)

Philco-Ford
MIM-72A  IR  0.5/4   15/3000   2.5    84  11  291/13/54    Chaparall
    An AIM-9D with control modifications. Fielded in 1968, 1972 for shipboard use

Western Electric
MIM-14B  CC   />140  ?         2.5  4500   ? 1250/80/212   Nike-Hercules
LIM-49A  CC   />750  ?         ?   13000 5MT 1683/107/300  Spartan

Martin Marietta
         CC   /40 1500/30k    ?    3400  kt  923/140/-     Sprint

USA (55%) / Germany (28%) / Italy (17%)
MEADS Uses the PAC-3 missile (for cost reasons).
   A standard fire unit, which is crewed by 19, consists of one search radar,
   two fire control radars (multifunction, can search too?), two operations centres,
   six 12-missile launchers. (One fire control radar, one OC and one launcher can work standalone.)


Military aviation - Missile non-comparison tables - >Surface to air missiles<